This week when we were talking about global development and poverty, organizations like "worldfund" and "world vision" came up quite a bit. In my opinion they were receiving some unfair criticism for their advertising techniques and how much money really goes to what you think it’s going to.
We discussed how their advertisement techniques were to make you feel guilty if you didn't donate and better about yourself if you did. We also talked about how in every picture on these websites there was a happy child. Even though sending them a goat or school supplies won't change their life, it's a start. The ASPCA does the same thing, in every one of their commercials there are sad, abused, caged, homeless animals, how can you not want to give them a loving home. This technique worked for my family and now we have our awesome dog Sally. This technique is the best option they’ve got
I also heard that the best way to make a difference is to go to where this poverty and development is and help hands on. I agree this is the best way, but most people can't drop everything and go. People have families and jobs to worry about as well. For most people the only way to help is to send money and/or goods. When it comes to the question “how can I be sure my money goes to a useful cause?” You usually have to do your own research on that because each organization varies. For example I provided a link that says how much of your money World Vision donates. The percentage that doesn’t go is used to keep their organization running.
In conclusion these organizations are needed and do serve a purpose. What I think we really need to focus on is building infrastructure and giving interest free or very low interest loans so that these people can start their own businesses. I never really discussed this topic before I came to AU, would you agree with my proposal?
http://www.worldvision.org/content.nsf/sponsor/for-sponsors-donation-integrity
Alex, you make a great argument with your case of giving interest free or very low loans to people who are so burdened with poverty they lack opportunity. I appreciate the fact that you pointed out one of the main reasons people chose to give to charities is so they can feel like they are contributing their part to the betterment of society. The claim to make a “real” difference hands on experience is necessary is not true at all. It is impossible for a large majority of American’s to put aside their work, families, home, and responsibility even for as little as a week and go and volunteer. While I, like you, am not putting down this behavior I think outside criticism for organizations who take donations to go and do similar type of charity work is out of line. However, it is the responsibility of the donor to use their funds wisely and to make sure whichever organization they should chose donate money to they not only agree with the principles but are in understanding of where the money is going.
ReplyDeleteYour suggestion is built off of the mircofinance option that was brought up in class. I think it’s a perfect resource as one of the tools Americans should consider if they want to help a certain demographic of people and their desire to start their business. Also, Microfinance can be financed by not just individuals but several different sectors of the population as well. Several Microfinance programs are funded by loans, grants, guarantees and investments from individuals, philanthropists, social investors, local banks, foundations, governments, and international institutions.